OBSERVATIONS ON THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF PUPPETRY


CHAPTER FIVE

 

CONCLUSION

 

    What stands out most clearly is that a definite trend from the East to the West can be discerned for the diffusion of puppets, especially shadow plays, during our era. But we are sadly lacking any detailed descriptions of puppets, puppet shows and their plays in the ancient days, whether in old documents, literature or art. India especially maintained their traditions and literature only by oral transmission since very ancient times. Only those arts supported by the courts and kings merited any mention; puppetry being a folk art, was seldom recorded until the start of the Christian era.
    We may be forced to admit that shadow plays were prevalent in the East,at least by 200 BC - probably originating in India - then the later appearance of rod and glove puppets in our era AD followed out of this puppetry form. Marionettes likely developed from automata and primitive puppet displays, which in turn seem to have been a separate development that originated in ancient Egypt, from rituals and ceremonies performed using string-operated figurines.
 


BIBLIOGRAPHY and REFERENCES


And, Metin.    Karagoz, Turkish Shadow Theatre, 1975.
Baird, Bil.    The Art of the Puppet, 1965.
Batchelder, Marjorie H.   Rod-puppets and the Human Theatre, 1947.
Blackstone., Kathryn R.   Women in the Footsteps of the Buddha: Struggle for Liberation in the Therigatha, 1998.
Brandon, James R., ed.   The Cambridge Guide to Asian Theatre, 1993.
Broadbent, R. J.    History of Pantomime, 1901.
Brunet, Jacques.    "Attempt at a Historical Outline of the Shadow Theatres", in Traditional Drama and Music of Southeast Asia, Mohd. Taib Osman, ed., 1974: pp.127-129.
Cames, Gerard.    Allegories et Symboles dans L'Hortus Deliciarum, 1971.
Chakraborty, Sunil.    "The Origin and Perspective of the Word 'Pat'", in The Patas and Patuas of Bengal, Sankar Sen Gupta, ed., 1973: pp. 85-94.
Choondal, Chummar.    Studies in Folklore of Kerala, 1978.
Christopher, Milbourne.    The Illustrated History of Magic, 1973.
Cohen, John.    Human Robots in Myth and Science, 1966.
Collier, John Payne.    Punch and Judy, 1828.
Colson, F. H., & Whitaker, G. H., trans.    Philo, 1968.
Contractor, Meher.    The Shadow Puppets of India, 1984.
Contractor, Meher.    "Shadow Puppets", and "Rod Puppets of Bengal", in Marg 3, June 1968.
Coomaraswamy, Ananda K.    "Picture Showmen" in The Indian Historical Quarterly, vol. V, 1929.
Cousins, J. H.    "Dance-Drama and Shadow-play" in The Arts and Crafts of Kerala, 1970: pp, 211-212.
Crawfurd, John.    A Descriptive Dictionary of the Indian Islands & Adjacent Countries, 1856.
Currell, David.    The Complete Book of Puppet Theatre, 1987.
Daiken, Leslie.    Children's Toys Throughout the Ages, 1953.
Davies, J. L., & Vaughan, David J.    The Republic of Plato, 1929.
de Wit., Augusta.    Java: Facts & Fancies, 1905.
Dolby, William.     "The Origins of Chinese Puppetry", in Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, vol.LXI, 1978: pp. 97-120.
Dolby, William.    A History of Chinese Drama, 1976.
Early, Alice K.    English Dolls, Effigies, and Puppets, 1955.
Enthoven, R. E.    The Tribes and Castes of Bombay, vol. I, "Kilikets": pp. 231-236.
Fairclough, H. Rushton, trans.    Horace: Satires, Epistles and Ars Poetica, 1970.
Farquharson, A. S. L.    The Meditations of Emperor Marcus Antonius, vol. I & lI, 1944.
Finkenzeller, R. & Zieher, W.  Chess: A Celebration of 2000 Years, 1989.
Fitzgerld, Edward, trans.   Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam, Random House, 1947.
Fraser, Antonia.    A History of Toys, 1966.
Gitford, William.    "A Tale of a Tub" in The Works of Ben Jonson, 1846: p. 407.
Godley, A. D., trans.    Herodotus, Book II, 1967.
Grunfeld, Frederic V., ed.   Games of the World, 1975.
Gulick, Charles Burton, trans.  Athenaeus: The Deipnosophists, Vol. I, 1969.
Gupta, S. P.    The Roots of Indian Art, 1980.
Hall, Stanley G., & Ellis, A. Caswell. A Study of Dolls, 1897.
Harding, Stan.    "The Ramayana Shadow-Play in India" in Asia, April 1935: pp. 234-235.
Hein, Norvin.    The Miracle Plays of Mathura, 1972.
Heinsius, Maria.    Der Paradiesgarten der Harrad van Landsberg, 1968.
Hercie, Emanuel.    Folk Toys, 1951.
Hillebrandt, Alfred.    "Zur Geschichte des indischen Dramas" in Zeitschrift der Duetschen Morgenlandischen Gesellschaft, vol. 72, 1918: pp. 227-232.
Holt, Claire.    Art in Indonesia: Continuities and Change, 1967.
Joseph, Helen Haiman.    A Book of Marionettes, 1920.
Jowett, B., & Campbell, Lewis.     Plato's Republic. The Greek Text: Vol l, Notes: Vol. III, 1894.
Jowett, B., trans.    Plato's The Republic, 1941.
K., Donna & Grosvenor, Gilbert M.    "Bali by the Back Roads" in The National Geographic, vol. 136, no.5, Nov. 1969: pp.656-697.
Kahle, Paul.    "Islamische Schattenspielfiguren aus Egypten" in Der Islam, vol. 1, 1910: pp. 264-299.
Keith, A. B.    The Sanskrit Drama, 1924.
Khaznadar, Francoise & Cherif.    Le Theatre D'Ombres, 1978.
Konow, Sten.    The Indian Drama (The Sanskrit Drama). Trans, S. N. Ghosal, 1969.
Krisnamurthy, Hanur, ed.    "Puppetry", in Encyclopaedia of the Folk Culture of Karnataka, 1991: pp. 383-405.
Landau, J. M.    "Shadow Plays in the Near East," in Edoth, vol. III, nos. 1-2., 1947, 1948.
Lee, Desmond.    Plato: The Republic. Second Edition, 1976.
Leibrecht, Philipp.    "Gesichtpunkte zu einer Geschichte des Puppenspiels" in Das Literarische Echo, October 1920 - October 1921: pp. 1211-1214.
Lloyd, Alan B.    Herodotus. Book Il, Commentary 1-98, 1976.
Lord, Isabel Ely, ed.    The Diary of Samuel Pepys, 1660-1669, n.d.
Maindron, Ernest.    Marionnettes et Guignols, 1900.
Mair, Victor H.    Painting and Performance, 1988, 1996 paperback edition.
Malkin, Michel R.    Traditional and Folk Puppets of the World, 1977.
Mansouri, S. M. Ei.    Art-Culture of India & Egypt, 1959.
March, Benjamin.    Chinese Shadow-figure Plays and their Making, 1938.
Meinhard, H.    "The Javanese Wayang and its Indian Prototype" in Man, July 1939, vol. 39, Summary 94: pp. 109-111.
Meserve, Walter J., & Mollie Ann. A Chronological Outline of World Theatre, 1992.
Morab, S. G,    The Killekyatha: Nomadic Folk Artists of Northern Mysore, 1977.
Muljono., Sri.    "Performance of Wayang Purwa Kulit (Shadow Play)" in Traditional Drama and Music of Southeast Asia, Mohan. Taib Osman, ed., 1974: pp. 58- 81.
Nicoll, Allardyce.    Masks, Mimes, and Miracles, 1931.
Oppeheimer, Stephen.    Eden in the East: The Drowned Continent of Southeast Asia, 1998.
Pani, Jiwan.    Ravana Chhaya, n.d.
Pischel, Richard.    The Home of the Puppet Play, 1902, not seen. See Ridgeway, p. 159.
Pring, J. T., compiler.   The Oxford Dictionary of Modern Greek, 1989.
Raffles, Sir Thomas Stamford.  The History of Java, vol. I, second edition, 1830.
Raghavan, V.    "Picture Showmen: Mankha" in The Indian Historical Quarterly, vol. 12, 1936, p.524.
Rassers, W. H.    "On the Origin of the Javanese Theatre" (1931) in Panji, the Culture Hero, 1982: pp.93-215.
Reiniger, Lotte    Shadow Theatres and Shadow Films, 1970.
Richards, I. A.    Plato's Republic, 1966.
Ridgeway, William.    Dramas and Dramatic Dances of Non-European Races, 1915.
Roberts, J. M.    The Pelican History of the World, 1981.
Rolfe, John C., trans    The Attic Nights of Aulus Gellius. Vol. III, 1968.
Sadwelkar, Baburao.    "Chitrakathi Tradition of Pinguli", in The Performing Arts, Marg, 1982.
Saxena, Asha.    Ancient Greek and Indian Theatre, 1997.
Schlegel, Gustave.    Review of Stewart Culin, "Korean Games with notes on the corresponding games of China and Japan" (University of Pennysylvania, 1895) in T'oung Pao, VII, 1896: pp. 99-100.
Schlegel, Gustave.    Review of Georg Jacob, "Die turkische Volkslittertur" (1901) in T'oung pao, Series II, Vol II, 1901: pp. 200-202.
Schrieder, Frank.    "Indonesia: The Young and Troubled Island Nation" in The National Geographic, vol. 119, no. 5, May 1961: pp.579-627.
Scott, A. C.    The Theatre in Asia, 1972.
Sen, Amulyachandra.    Asoka's Edicts, 1956.
Sheppard, D. H. M.   "The Khmer Shadow Play and its Links with Ancient India" in Journal of the Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society vol. 41, pt. 1., 1968: pp. 199-204.
Shih, Chung-Wen.    The Golden Age of Chinese Drama: Yuan Tsa-chu, 1976.
Simmen, Rene    The World of Puppets. 1972.
Sorensen, Niels Roed.    "Tolu Bommalu Kattu: Shadow Theatre Re: Andhra Pradesh" in Journal of South Asian Literature, vol. X, 1975: pp. 1-19.
Speaight, George.    The History of the English Puppet Theatre, 1955.
Speaight, George.    "Puppetry" in The New Encyclopaedia Britannica, vol. 26, 1995: pp. 450-457.
Stache-Rosen, Valentina.    "On the Shadow Theatre in India" in German Scholars On India, 1976: pp. 276-285.
Stalberg, Roberta Helmer.   China's Puppets, 1984.
Stern, C. H.    Not seen. See Batchelder, note on p. xiv.
Sweeney, Amin.    Malay Shadow Puppets, 1972.
Tarlekar, G. H.    Studies in the Natyasastra, l975.
Thurston, Edgar.    Castes and Tribes of Southern India, vol. III-K, 1909.
Tilakasiri, J.    The Puppet Theatre of Asia, I969.
Ulbricht, H.    Wayang Purwa, Shadows of the Past, 1970.
Varadpande, M. L.    Ancient Indian and Indo-Greek Theatre, 1981.
Venu, G.    Tolpava Koothu: Shadow Puppets of Kerala, 1990.
van Boehn, Max.    Dolls and Puppets. Trans. Josephine Nicoll, 1932.
Warmoes, Vasiliki Antonakis.  Karaghiozi Shadow Theater. Montreal: unpublished Master of Arts thesis, Concordia University, 1989.
White, Gwen. Antique Toys and their Background, 1971.
Wijesekera, O. H. De. A.    "Buddhist Evidence for the Early Existence of Drama" in The Indian Historical Quarterly, vol. 17, no. 2, June 1941: pp. 196-206.
Williams, Joanna.    The Two-Headed Deer: Illustrations of the Ramayana in Orissa, 1996.
Winans, Samuel Ross, ed.   Xenophon Symposium, 1881.
Woodcock, George.    The Greeks in India, 1966.
Yousof, Ghulam-Sarwar.   Dictionary of Traditional South-East. Asian Theatre, 1994.
 


PICTURE REFERENCES

(refer to Bibliography above for fuller details of the sources)

Chapter One:
Dancing Dwarfs - Picture source: http://homepage.powerup.com.au/~ancient/museum7.htm
String operated figure - Picture source: http://homepage.powerup.com.au/~ancient/museum7.htm
Articulated Indian figurine - Picture source: Gupta, S. P. "The Roots of Indian Art"
Roman comic character - Picture source: Maindron, Ernest. "Marionnettes et Guignols"
Ancient Greek doll of ivory - Picture source: Unknown, obsolete web page
Modern-day opera dei pupi - Picture source: Simmen, Rene. "The World of Puppets"

 

Chapter Two:

A modern tholubomalatta show, in Andhra Pradesh - Picture source: Unknown local library book

A Wayang Beber Performance, 1900 - Picture source: Mair, Victor H. "Painting and Performance"

Shadow of a Wayang Kulit Puppet - Picture source: Ulbricht, H.  "Wayang Purwa, Shadows of the Past"

Wayang Kulit Performance in Java - Picture source: Jane Turner, ed. "The Dictionary of Art," Volume 15, Indonesia VI, Theatre, by Ward Keeler, 1996

Javanese Wayang Kulit in action - Pictures source: Schrieder, Frank. "Indonesia: The Young and Troubled Island Nation" in The National Geographic

Wayang Klitik Puppets & A Wayang Golek Puppet - Pictures source: Simmen, Rene. "The World of Puppets"

 

Chapter Three:
Chinese Rod Puppets - Picture source: Joseph, Helen Haiman. "A Book of Marionettes"
A Balinese Shadow Figure - Picture source: Ulbricht, H. "Wayang Purwa, Shadows of the Past"
Two examples of a narrator in puppet shows - Picture source (left): Early, Alice K. "English Dolls, Effigies, and Puppets", and Picture source (right): van Boehn, Max. "Dolls and Puppets"

 

Chapter Four:
King Solomon on his throne observing the "show" - Picture source: Heinsius, Maria. "Der Paradiesgarten der Harrad van Landsberg."
This picture is often thought to depict only a children's toy or game - Picture source: Simmen, Rene. "The World of Puppets"

"From India, chess made its way to Persia..." - Picture source: Grunfeld, Frederic V., ed. "Games of the World"
"Mediaeval Egyptian shadow puppets [were] discovered in Menzala by Professor Kahle early this century." (See pictures.) - Picture source: Kahle, Paul. "Islamische Schattenspielfiguren aus Egypten" in Der Islam, vol. 1
...identical to those used centuries later by English Punch and Judy showmen (see pictures) - Picture source (top): Time-Life Books: "What Life was Like in the Age of Chivalry", 1997, Picture source (bottom): Early, Alice K."English Dolls, Effigies, and Puppets."


Introduction
Chapter One - Toys, Dolls, and Automata
Chapter Two - Scenic Shades
Chapter Three - Puppetry Operational Procedures & Other Thoughts
Chapter Four - Europe and Asia in the Era A.D.